Wednesday, July 2, 2025

Delhi & Haryana's Latest Move: A Breath of Fresh Air or a Blow to the Common Man?


The National Capital Region (NCR), including Delhi and parts of Haryana, is once again at the forefront of a contentious environmental policy. Effective July 1, 2025, a new directive mandates that "end-of-life" vehicles – specifically diesel vehicles older than 10 years and petrol vehicles older than 15 years (which would primarily encompass BS4 and older emission standards) – will no longer be allowed to refuel. To enforce this, petrol pumps are being equipped with advanced sensors and CCTV cameras to identify and deny fuel to non-compliant vehicles.
While the stated aim is to curb alarming levels of air pollution, this policy has ignited a fierce debate, raising critical questions about its legal standing, practical implementation, environmental efficacy, and perhaps most importantly, its significant impact on the economy and the pockets of ordinary citizens.
The Legal Landscape: A Stance Rooted in Precedent
This latest move isn't entirely new territory for the judiciary. The ban on older vehicles in Delhi-NCR finds its roots in directives from the National Green Tribunal (NGT) and subsequent reinforcement by the Supreme Court. As early as 2018, the Supreme Court upheld the NGT's ruling to prohibit diesel vehicles older than 10 years and petrol vehicles older than 15 years from plying in Delhi. The current policy is essentially an enforcement mechanism to actualize these existing judicial orders.
The courts have consistently emphasized public health and the right to clean air, often prioritizing environmental concerns over individual vehicle ownership rights. This gives the government's current policy a strong legal backing, as it aligns with previous judicial pronouncements aimed at combating severe air pollution.
Implementation Woes and Arbitrary Concerns: More Questions Than Answers?
While legally supported, the implementation of this policy raises several eyebrows:
 * "End-of-Life" Definition: The blanket age-based definition of "end-of-life" is a major point of contention. A well-maintained 10-year-old diesel car could potentially be less polluting than a poorly maintained newer vehicle. This age-based ban fails to account for actual emission levels, which could be scientifically determined through rigorous PUC (Pollution Under Control) checks.
 * Sensor Reliability: The reliance on sensors and ANPR (Automatic Number Plate Recognition) cameras at petrol pumps for real-time identification of non-compliant vehicles needs to be foolproof. Any errors could lead to unnecessary harassment for vehicle owners.
 * Lack of Scrappage Incentives: A critical missing piece is a robust and attractive vehicle scrappage policy. Without adequate incentives, owners are left with valuable assets suddenly deemed worthless, forcing them into a difficult financial corner.
 * Pan-NCR Uniformity: While the policy targets Delhi and parts of Haryana, the interconnectedness of the NCR means a patchwork implementation can create confusion and loopholes, with vehicles simply crossing borders to refuel.
Economic Ripples: A Hole in the Pockets of Voters
The economic ramifications of this policy are substantial and immediate, particularly for the middle class and small businesses:
 * Sudden Depreciation of Assets: Millions of vehicle owners, who paid road tax for 15 years (even for diesel vehicles that are now banned at 10 years), find their significant investments rendered valueless overnight. This is a direct financial hit for families who often rely on their vehicles for daily commute, livelihoods, or essential services.
 * Forced New Vehicle Purchases: The policy is expected to drive a surge in demand for new vehicles, providing a boost to the automobile industry and government tax revenues. However, for many, purchasing a new car is a significant financial burden, often requiring loans and stretching household budgets.
 * Impact on Livelihoods: Small traders, delivery drivers, and service providers who depend on their older vehicles for their livelihood are disproportionately affected. Without a viable alternative, many face the prospect of unemployment or significant disruption to their businesses.
 * Exacerbating Economic Stress: In an economy still grappling with various challenges, such a broad-brush policy adds another layer of financial stress on the populace, creating discontent and frustration among voters.
Environmental Efficacy: A Band-Aid on a Deeper Wound?
While the intent is clear – to reduce air pollution – questions linger about the actual environmental impact and whether this policy addresses the root causes:
 * Vehicular vs. Other Pollutants: While vehicular emissions are a significant contributor to air pollution, they are not the sole factor. Industrial emissions, construction dust, road dust, and stubble burning also play a major role. A holistic approach addressing all sources is crucial for sustainable improvement.
 * Focus on Age, Not Emission: The arbitrary age cut-off might not always align with actual pollution levels. A well-maintained older vehicle might pollute less than a poorly maintained newer one. A more effective approach could involve stringent emission testing and enforcement, penalizing genuinely polluting vehicles regardless of age.
 * Shifting the Problem: Banning older vehicles from Delhi-NCR might simply shift the problem to other regions if these vehicles are sold off and continue to ply elsewhere, negating the overall environmental benefit.
A Call for Balance and Compassion
There is no denying the urgent need to combat air pollution in Delhi and Haryana. However, a policy that significantly impacts millions of citizens, particularly the economically vulnerable, demands a more nuanced and compassionate approach.
Instead of arbitrary age-based bans, the government should explore:
 * Robust Scrappage Policies with Fair Compensation: Offering attractive incentives for owners to scrap their older vehicles, possibly with subsidies for purchasing newer, compliant vehicles or electric alternatives.
 * Strengthened Emission Testing: Implementing strict and transparent PUC norms across all vehicles, irrespective of age, with severe penalties for non-compliance.
 * Investment in Public Transport: A truly effective solution lies in drastically improving and expanding public transportation infrastructure, making it a viable and attractive alternative to private vehicles.
 * Addressing Other Pollution Sources: A sustained and comprehensive effort to tackle industrial emissions, construction dust, and agricultural burning is equally vital.
The new fuel ban in Delhi and parts of Haryana, while legally defensible on environmental grounds, presents a complex challenge. It's a stark reminder that policies, even those with noble intentions, must be carefully crafted to consider their broader societal and economic implications, ensuring that the burden of environmental responsibility doesn't disproportionately fall on the shoulders of the common citizen. The "hole in the pockets of voters" might just be too deep to ignore.

Thursday, November 24, 2022

Words of wisd

- prisoners in India a state subject
- center provides assistance for maintainence, modernisation, training etc.
- earlier women were treated as goddess now the times have changed
- a women is the sole holder for any house with several roles to be played like wife, sister, mother, daughter etc
- if you today think positive the change you make will be positive
- no system can help you change but only you can help you change
- as per dna report about 3700 women prisoners were in jail till 8thSep2014
- as per India today the women and children specially unwittingly become part of sordid system
- lack of family support makes them dependent on other prisoners
- Story of Nisanjael ( provided in the second email which was sent for motivational talk)
• Inmates not ready to make positive changes
• It makes it easy for the officers to shun their responsibilities because of this attitude
• It's not the fault of the system but of the attitude of prisoners
• If you do not change your attitude towards life and take a lesson from this then no one can help improve the various problems being faced by you in this system
- what you can do is plan to bring a change, educate others as to why not do such things ,get linked to Mahila yojna and help other women, serve your family, if your alone then government has several schemes under which they will promote women entrepreneurs which means that you all can together work and make a factory of what ever you are good in making may it be biscuits kr suits only like the Kalagram in Chandigarh holds a festival for all artisans giving them a huge platform to sell their products
- classification policies don't offer pursuit of job skills, nor maintaining clean disciplinary conduct, publishing credentials etc
- prisoners want to advance like every other person
- for this a first initiative must be taken by the person themselves
- all prisoners want positive change and create a better bond with their family
- want to reconcile with the society
- think of your family before you do such things
- think that what if your children if single then parents will have to face because of your fault from not only the police administration but also the society
- for a better future make a right change today

Citizenship

Citizenship
2 parts
(1) on 26/1/1950
- Domicile (ar.5)
> 2 conditions :
A) indian domicile on commencement
B) • born in India • either parent in India • O.R for 5 yrs before commencement
> 2 types
A) origion
B) choice
- from pak (ar.6)
> 2 types
1) before 19/6/1948
O.r since migration
2) after 19/6/1948
Recides atleast 6 months before application
- to pak (ar.7)
If he leaves India for pak ar. 5 & 6 won't apply to him after 1/3/1947
- indian origin (ar.8)
1) either parent or grand parent born In India
2) o.r o/s india deemed to be Indian only if parent is I.O
Ar. 9 -> taking citizenship voluntarily of any other country
(2) Ar. 11 -> after commencement
On or after 26/1/1950
A) birth (u/s 3)
B) decent (u/s 4)
C) registration (u/s 5)
D) Naturalisation (u/s 6)
E) taking territory (u/s 7)
They all come under the citizenship act of india, 1955
Termination
1) renunciation (u/s 8)
Voluntry leaving
2) termination (u/s 9)
Cancelation bcoz they took another citizenship of another state or country
3) deprivation (u/s 10)
Central govt removes it
Note - if the govt gets a person who applies for citizenship and is a distinguished member in fields like arts, literature, scientists, human peace then no condition like intention or knowledge of language or oath or good character need to be seen he can be a citizen by discretion of the central govt.

Sunday, May 29, 2022

Time a crucial Factor In Politics

With the death of the popular punjabi music singer today , I.e 22.5.22, we see a lot of paid media buzzing and hypeing news to convince people of rivalry for personal vendata in the name of personal protection .
This time when media is busy giving statements of 10 to 35 and 200 guns rounds some questions strike my mind at this crucial time when these events are following up :-
1. Punjab has a new government which has just yesterday taken away security
2. 3rd attack in Punjab where not much damage has happened
3. Election of himachal and Gujrat are round and the bjp looks in a bad position in the city from where pm belongs .
4. BJP minister is arrested from another state.
5. Aap is busy with correcting its image by changing a minister alleged of corruption.

Note :- I'm reminded of the rpg attack in mohali where only 1 wondow broke 
I'm also reminded of gun shots in SAS Nagar where no one died and then this, but in this lieu flags of khalistan are found to be risen in himachal only.

Now the questions I wish my reads to address are a mix and as follows :-

Now in medical legal terms the incident doesn't match with reality plus logics in the following sequence :-
1. His mouth and nose are full of blood bubbles - related to liver , stomach and heart disease 
2. His car is hit with 10 bullets as per record shown and 3 or 4 of which only hit his stomach . 
False statements of 35 and 200 rounds being rumored 
3. He has a security going behind who did nothing 
4. His mother who's only son died isn't in pain but in political vendata 
5. None of the people in the car except driver died 
6. Issue of security is raised by bjp only openly in media no one else is putting a statement 
7. He owns big cars and is found in his thar who on being hit is found with open hair whereas he himself has more than 10's of guns

Logics
1. On seeing gun man ahead he stops car instead of running 
2. His wipers are on meaning he lost control and didn't take our his own gun
3. He is found in casuals when he is popular as much as the PM
4. His security moves behind and no terrorist so called is ever shot
5. Connections of people already in jail who have no connection is brought 


So is the political vendata bigger than a life ?
Are elections more important ?
Is the security so weak that we now want drones ?
Are vips so prone ?
People is jails have such good access without support of the power in present ?
Clean chit is given to intelligence?

Think as a common man ...
Vote for good not for goons 

Sunday, April 10, 2022

Need for a Governer


Respected Members of Society
Greetings,

The Golden Era was dominated by Britishers and while we took our independence we adopted their model of governance creating upon a watch tool mechanism called as a Governer.
Article 154 and 155 of the Indian Constitution empowered the Governer , who is a sparrow of the central leadership for all works and milonitoring of the States workings and it's development.
But with time the use of this has become similar to the condition of our independent bodies such as the ED, IT, Media , Judiciary and all other breaking the 3 pillars of the foundation of Democracy.
Today Delhi has become the best example of misuse of Power by the central government upon fulfilling its philosophy of an Orange Nation.
The manifesto which is the basis of the contract for the purpose of which votes are given is no longer honoured by the judiciary in scare and all the judiciary is being filled in is with dump of political mindset ignoring any and all of the same.
With such a development it is time the Opposition got united as One Body under 1 Title to propose a Bill for making Elected members of Rajya Sabha as the eyes and ears of the Central Ministry and Abolishing the powers of the Governor before the centre abolishes all powers vested to the people of India and Various State Governments.
Hence with this email we on behalf of India Risee wish that a note shall be pressed upon our suggestions to see a Progressive India Rather than a State run by uneducated goons raping and killing minorities and all the supports and voices that come against their views .
Only if the Opposition stands united can we be able to Save India.
With the consegitive wrong choices being made by the old sole opposition today the state of affairs has became a scary reason for the country to stand affirm and as one opposition against those who wish to buy choosen MP and MLA openly to form their own government at all costs of democracy

Jai Hind

Regards 
Team IndiaRisee
(A social facebook page initiative)
Error Icon
Recipient inbox full
Your message couldn't be delivered to trinamool.yuva@aitmc.org. Their inbox is full or it's receiving too much mail at the moment.
LEARN MORE
Warning!This link will take you to a third-party site
The response from the remote server was:
522 5.7.1 <trinamool.yuva@aitmc.org>: Recipient address rejected: Requested mail action aborted: exceeded storage allocation Please see http://support.mailhostbox.com/email-administrators-guide-error-codes/ for explanation of the problem.

Show quoted text

Wednesday, March 30, 2022

Open Letter - Punjab Issues

Dear sir
Greetings of the day

We are a small group of legal professionals who run under one name with some other friends of various provisions for raising the voice of the people that is unable to be heard during thr course of any Legal Proceeding. 

It brings within all of us a big sigh of relief when we see you talking opening on the open collation between the relatives, I.e akali and caption. 

That further we would like to appraise you that apart from politics we as advocates and social workers are fighting the legal battle on the major issues of which we shall need your support to take this lead forward. 

That further we are backed by several small stake holders from both Haryana and Punjab.

That further the problems being faced are in brief below :-

1) RERA Nexus

With the implementation of Rera a big scam is being played in the entire state of Punjab. The Chairperson and our fight is left to the wasted interest. The Government has legalized the illegal colonies for which there is no power and under section 69 of the same act the Government of Punjab should have penalized the developers and made a positive start which they have failed. Today the state is licensing buildings without license to develop because the chairperson of rera is a close aid to the caption and needs a change. The chairperson needs to be a Judicial man of integrity. Further more there are a lot of scams from day 1 which needs to see the light of the day.

2) Empanelment 

That further you must be aware that it the AG of Punjab has already been accused of plundering the government of Punjab by calling advocates from Delhi to honour and favour them where is the truth is that the entire AG office of Punjab is bestowed and in circle around Mr Nanda who is again a close aide of captain and needs to be sent back to his home town Delhi for failing to get to the interest of Punjab.

3) Registration

The process of registration has taken a U turn vis-a-vis Punjab as money is opened the demanded making the lives of common man. SINCE AFTER RERA PEOOLE THOUGHT it will become easy but because how certain selfish motives it has become a mess 2 and sure that the central plan of Punjab ab is passed in the same manner the illegal colonies of Punjab are immediately stopped the allotment of land is done in an open basis and the development being done near the farmhouse of chief minister of Punjab clash the hotel of Ex Chief Minister of Punjab is done as per act and not favoritism.

4) implementation of policies

Punjab miserably fails to get its policy implemented throughout the nation only for the reason that the heads of the Institutions are made in such a way that they obliged the chief minister and his allies without having any version of growing the wealth of the state they are involved in looting the state through various operations.

5) use of land

The master plan of Punjab is different than from the actual plan being imposed in Punjab. Thereby meaning that Punjab is headed for a dumb by killing its own farmers and grabbing the land of its farmers was a purpose to satisfy the needs two people primarily e near and around their area of investment of properties in Punjab.

6) judiciary

Amongst many other issues Judiciary is one of the biggest issue today where only the clauses of the government are being promoted without having any merit are made either senior advocates for judicial advocates in various tribunals as well as quotes including the high court and are openly involved in favouring the government as well as encouraging mafia and thoughts of the central government for their own promotion beyond the constitution of India 

7) appointments in tribunals

Appointment and tribunals is done of people close to the chief minister of Punjab which further dents the image and the need and purpose for developing such institutions the pool has taken out notifications only to benefit the people close to the chief minister and make the remaining mass of Sulphur by non-implementation of false notifications and promises to look into to the matters and compensate the government for what happened ants causing another use deficit in the pockets of the government of Punjab

8) Police recruitment

That Among many other issues Police recruitment still stands at still and favours are still being given to close AIDS of ministers and rather by putting aside the police Reforms Act 2006 which is a success in Kerala and a major way to blow up the Nexus between the government and to join the connection of the Government and its people.



That in order to try our best to save people and their interests from the cruel system of judiciary we have been fighting on both legal and social levels but with Punjab taking the lead and giving us assurance of rise in Haryana



 your kind attention. Support as well as Interference in removal , transformation and systemisation of the Punjab Model that as


Monday, March 7, 2022

Russia Ukraine War and Role of Opposition - An open Letter

Dear Members of INC,
Greetings

Since the start of the war between the 2 nations Russia and Ukraine only our paid media Has been promoting Sh. Modi ji to resolve the tension with his powerful words of saying Thank God I came back alive.
It becomes important for us as the only opposition to spread the message of Citizens first and take this opportunity on time to take the right attractive headline for elections.
The issues that will influence hereon shall be :-
1. Selling Airline
2. Crying videos of students 
3. Congress interaction with students in Ukraine against Indian Government and Media 
4. Sh. Rahul Gandhi talking to the Foreign Minister in Person for evacuation and receiving flights by various senior members of Our Congress to take the spot light away from these liars in BJP
5. Interviews of Congress stating stands our Previous PM took and helped people evacuate at times of need without to much of hoarding
6. Exposing the sitting government on their short comings
7. Meeting of neerby Congress states together in 1 area and platform for this purpose.


If only this is timely used the issue shall become an asset for telling people about the difference of intention between both parties.

Thank You

Regards 
Team India Risee