Thursday, July 16, 2015

Net Neutrality: What You Need to Know Now


 What is Net Neutrality?
Net Neutrality is the Internet’s guiding principle: It preserves our right to communicate freely online. This is the definition of an open Internet.
 
Net Neutrality means an Internet that enables and protects free speech. It means that Internet service providers should provide us with open networks — and should not block or discriminate against any applications or content that ride over those networks. Just as your phone company shouldn't decide who you can call and what you say on that call, your ISP shouldn't be concerned with the content you view or post online.
 
Without Net Neutrality, cable and phone companies could carve the Internet into fast and slow lanes. An ISP could slow down its competitors' content or block political opinions it disagreed with. ISPs could charge extra fees to the few content companies that could afford to pay for preferential treatment — relegating everyone else to a slower tier of service. This would destroy the open Internet.
 
 
 

What was the FCC’s ‘Open Internet Order’?

The FCC’s 2010 order was intended to prevent broadband Internet service providers from blocking or interfering with traffic on the Web. The Open Internet Order was generally designed to ensure the Internet remained a level playing field for all — that's the principle we call Net Neutrality (we say “generally,” since the FCC’s rules prohibited wired ISPs from blocking and discriminating against content, while allowing wireless ISPs to discriminate against but not block websites).
 
In its January 2014 ruling, the court said that the FCC used a questionable legal framework to craft the Open Internet Order and lacked the authority to implement and enforce those rules.
 

Did the court rule against Net Neutrality? 

No. The court ruled against the FCC's ability to enforce Net Neutrality under the shaky legal foundation it established for those rules. The court specifically stated that its “task as a reviewing court is not to assess the wisdom of the Open Internet Order regulations, but rather to determine whether the Commission has demonstrated that the regulations fall within the scope of its statutory grant of authority.”
 
When the FCC made its 2010 open Internet rule, it relied on two decisions the Bush-era FCC made, rulings that weakened the FCC’s authority over broadband Internet access providers. Nothing in the January 2014 court decision prohibited the FCC from reversing those misguided decisions and reclassifying ISPs as common carriers.
 
In fact, both this decision and a prior Supreme Court decision showed that reclassification would provide the best means of protecting the open Internet.
 

What does ‘reclassify’ mean? 

When Congress enacted the 1996 Telecommunications Act, it didn’t want the FCC to treat websites and other Internet services the same way it treats the local access networks that enable people to get online. Congress understood that the owners of the access networks have tremendous gatekeeper power, and so it required the FCC to treat these network owners as “common carriers,” meaning they couldn’t block or discriminate against the content that flows across their networks to/from your computer.
 
However, in a series of politically motivated decisions first by FCC Chairman Michael Powell (now the cable industry’s top lobbyist) and then by FCC Chairman Kevin Martin, the FCC decided to classify broadband Internet access service as an “information service,” meaning that the law sees it as no different from a website like freepress.net or an online service like LexisNexis. These decisions removed the FCC’s ability to prohibit ISPs from blocking or discriminating against online content (it also removed the FCC’s ability to ensure that ISPs protect your privacy). 
 
In Verizon vs. FCC, the court stated that the FCC lacks authority because of “the Commission’s still-binding decision to classify broadband providers not as providers of ‘telecommunications services’ but instead as providers of ‘information services.’” 
 
On Feb. 26, the FCC voted to define broadband as what we all know it is — a connection to the outside world that is merely faster than the phone lines we used to use for dial-up access, phone calls and faxes.
 
Doing so gave the agency the strongest possible foundation for rules prohibiting discriminatory practices.
 

What did the FCC vote on?

The new rules, rooted in Title II of the Communications Act, ban throttling, blocking and paid prioritization.
 

Why is Net Neutrality important for businesses?

Net Neutrality is crucial for small business owners, startups and entrepreneurs, who rely on the open Internet to launch their businesses, create a market, advertise their products and services, and distribute products to customers. We need the open Internet to foster job growth, competition and innovation.
Net Neutrality lowers the barriers of entry for entrepreneurs, startups and small businesses by ensuring the Web is a fair and level playing field. It’s because of Net Neutrality that small businesses and entrepreneurs have been able to thrive on the Internet. They use the Internet to reach new customers and showcase their goods, applications and services.
No company should be able to interfere with this open marketplace. ISPs are by definition the gatekeepers to the Internet, and without Net Neutrality, they would seize every possible opportunity to profit from that gatekeeper control.
Without Net Neutrality, the next Google would never get off the ground.

Why is Net Neutrality important for communities of color?

The open Internet allows communities of color to tell their own stories and to organize for racial and social justice.
The mainstream media have failed to allow people of color to speak for themselves. And thanks to economic inequality and runaway media consolidation, people of color own just a handful of broadcast stations. The lack of diverse ownership is a primary reason why the media have gotten away with portraying communities of color stereotypically.
The open Internet gives marginalized voices opportunities to be heard. But without Net Neutrality, ISPs could block unpopular speech and prevent dissident voices from speaking freely online. Without Net Neutrality, people of color would lose a vital platform.
And without Net Neutrality, millions of small businesses owned by people of color wouldn't be able to compete against larger corporations online, which would further deepen the economic inequality in our nation’s most vulnerable communities.

So what can we do now?

The cable and phone companies — and their allies in Congress — willl do everything they can to dismantle this win.

Sunday, July 12, 2015

why not give away gas subsidy

 *Reform Act of 2014*
 1. No Tenure / No Pension: Parliamentarians collect a salary while in office but should not receive any pay when they're out of office. 
 2. Parliamentarians should purchase their own retirement plans, just as all Indians do.
 3. Parliamentarians should no longer vote themselves a pay raise. Their pay should be linked to the CPI or 3%, whichever is lower. 
 4. Parliamentarians should lose their current health care system and participate in the same health care system as the Indian people.
 5. Parliamentarians with tainted records, criminal charges & convictions, past or present should be summarily banned from the parliament and fighting election on any pretext or the other.
 6. Parliamentarians should equally abide by all laws they impose on the Indian people.
 7. All contracts with past and present Parliamentarians should be void effective 1/1/15 


The Indian people did not make this contract with them. Parliamentarians made all these contracts for themselves. Serving in Parliament is an honor, not a lucrative career. The Founding Fathers envisioned citizen legislators, so ours should serve their term(s), then go home and back to work. No surrender of subsidies like LPG by citizens unless all subsidies available to MPs and MLAs withdrawn including subsidised food in Parliament canteen 

Friday, June 26, 2015

Surviving LAMO Storm after Namo Victory....

The axe forgets, but the tree remembers.
This African proverb best explains the current plight of Rajasthan chief minister Vasundhara Raje, who is facing the toughest battle of her political life. One more push and the Dholpur Maharani could be dethroned.
Reports suggest the BJP leadership has refused to defend Raje and her son Dushyant, who is being called the party’s Robert Vadra. The BJP may in fact probe some of the charges against the ‘Maa-Beta’ sarkar and initiate action if she is found guilty.
Unlike Sushma Swaraj, who was defended by Rajnath Singh, Arun Jaitley and the RSS, nobody in the BJP is crying for Raje. “As regards with the Rajasthan issue is concerned, the details have to be taken into account. I think Vasundhara ji has spoken slightly yesterday (Tuesday), surely she will revert,” BJP leader Ravishankar Prasad said.
So, Raje is on her own.
The signs are ominous. On Wednesday, as TV channels screamed “off with the Queen’s head’ and called her a coward for running away from questions, Raje desperately tried to meet party chief Amit Shah. But Shah didn’t seem keen to meet her in a hurry.
Reuters
Reuters
The BJP’s problem is that it has realised Raje’s case is indefensible. The financial transactions between her son, Jhalawar MP Dushyant Singh, and Modi are almost similar to the deals between Vadra and DLF. The paper trail shows that he got nearly Rs 11 crore for a company that exists just on paper through the Mauritius route. This is a classic case of round-tripping of money and the paper trail points to slush funds being laundered. The BJP will look stupid defending an encore of Vadragate.
The case against Raje is scandalous. Modi has confessed that Raje supported his application for immigration in Britain and then tried to keep it a secret from the Indian authorities. If the allegation of helping a fugitive is proven, it could amount to treachery, even treason. If the case against Raje is proven, the BJP’s claim of being a party of nationalists would turn into a joke.
Raje’s defence depends on just one argument: that she didn’t sign the document pledging support to Modi’s immigration plea. But her silence on the issue, her inability to face the media, to fight her battle like Swaraj did, suggests Raje is at the mercy of her critics and the high command.
If Raje stands isolated today, much of it is her own fault. She has had a history of blackmailing the party leadership, throwing fits and bending in the direction of the wind. She has no permanent friends but life-long enemies.
In the summer of 2013, when Raje began her campaign from Charbhuja, she didn’t invite Narendra Modi. When Rajnath Singh, who was the BJP president then, began to speak, hundreds of workers started shouting ‘Modi, Modi’ to remind Raje of her folly. Over the next few weeks, Raje corrected her course and began leaning towards the Narendra Modi camp.
But, it is unlikely, the PM would have forgotten the slur.
Before that, she had threatened to quit if her demand for being made the state BJP president wasn’t accepted. To force the party’s hand, many legislators in the Raje camp submitted their resignation to her; some of them even suggested that they were ready to float a new party.
And, soon after the NDA won the election, Raje reportedly demanded that her son be made a minister in the Modi government. In the ensuing fight, Rajasthan — a state with 25 MPs— was completely overlooked and was allotted just one seat in the Cabinet (rape accused Nihalchand Meghwal).
Back then, the BJP didn’t have too many options. Elections were on the horizon; Raje was the party’s only mass leader and the Centre was weak. The internal dynamics within the BJP have changed dramatically since then. To use a famous Dilbert line, Raje, who was the bird then, is now the statue. As the muck gets thrown at her, her rivals would see this as an opportunity to teach her a lesson.
Many powerful forces are working against Raje. It can’t be just a coincidence that Lalit Modi himself revealed that she secretly tried to help him and then released ‘incriminating’ documents against her. Something must have gone horribly wrong between Modi and Raje over the past two years.
Raje may have forgotten some of the things she did in the past, but her rivals still remember them. This looks eerily similar to Badlapur.

Tuesday, March 10, 2015

Land Accusition Bill - 6 Main Points

The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Amendment) Bill, 2015, popularly known as Land bill, was adopted by the Lok Sabha on Tuesday. Here are the six important facts you need to know:-

1The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Amendment) Bill, 2015 seeks to Amend the Act of 2013 (LARR Act, 2013).

2The Bill creates five special categories of land use: 1. defence, 2. rural infrastructure, 3. affordable housing, 4. industrial corridors, and 5. infrastructure projects including Public Private Partnership (PPP) projects where the central government owns the land




3The Bill exempts the five categories from provisions of the LARR Act, 2013 which requires the consent of 80 per cent of land ownersto be obtained for private projects and that of 70 per cent of land owners for PPP 7projects.

4The Bill allows exemption for projects in these five categories from requiring Social Impact Assessment be done to identify those affected and from the restrictions on the acquisition of irrigated multi-cropped land imposed by LARR Act 2013.

5The Bill brings provisions for compensation, rehabilitation, and resettlement under other related Acts such as the National Highways Act and the Railways Act in consonance with the LARR Act.

6The Bill changes acquisition of land for private companies mentioned in LARR Act, 2013 to acquisition for ‘private entities’. A private entity could include companies, corporations and nonprofit organisations.

Railway Budget 2015: Mr Suresh Prabhu, CEO or politician?

Railways minister Suresh Prabhu has been given the challenging task to transform Indian Railways.
Economist Bibek Debroy chaired a committee to reconfigure the Railway Board as well as to suggest steps for resource mobilisation for major projects. The committee’s interim report is awaited.
su
In the meantime, the World Bank made a presentation to Prabhu outlining the experience of other countries in transforming their railway systems. It recommended that the Indian Railways be reconfigured along separate businesses and do away with the departmental structure. It was, however, constrained in the range of recommendations it put forward, since the Prime Minister had declared no change in ownership can take place.
So, the World Bank came up with anovel recommendation: of periodically having the Railway Board reviewed by a ‘supervisory board’. Apart from the Railway Board chairman, other members would be drawn from business, banking, and academia — but none from the government or political class.
The Acworth Committee had made a similar recommendation in 1923. But the government of the day scuttled the ability of the committee to function independently by filling it from within the government.
Even if a supervisory board is constituted, its ability to influence the functioning of the railways will be limited by the fact that it won’t be able to review the performance of the railway minister.
The railway minister wears two hats: a political one, and as head of one of the largest commercial organisations in the world. While Parliament is the correct forum for the review of the politician, for the Indian Railways ‘CEO’, a supervisory board would be the right forum.
There is another fly in the ointment. A commercial organisation is a department of the government subject to all government rules. Moreover, the officer cadre that manages the Indian Railways is the civil service with promotional and other incentive systems identical to other central services. Such a system works in accordance with the rules, at its own pace. Everything is time-bound.
Moreover, the Railway Board is not a board of a commercial organisation but an operational one. The seven members manage the railways on a day-to-day basis where each functional member is supreme in his area and the chairman arbitrates when two or more functions are involved. This arrangement remains effective and it manages to run 14,300 trains daily in very challenging conditions.
Even as it is a department of the government, the railways remains acommercial enterprise. The government can’t escape taking decisions as shareholder and as board of directors. Parliament performs the function of shareholders, approving the budget and laying down what it can and can’t do.
Similarly, the Union Cabinet performs the role of the board of directors, since it makes all the top appointments, and any decisions regarding fare structure and other policy issues. However, neither Parliament nor the Cabinet thinks of itself as shareholders or board of directors. Across both fora is the railway minister, performing the function of a managing director.
Over the years, railway ministers have used funds for political commitments at the cost of commercial viability. Suresh Prabhu has a choice before him. Does he to want take on the mantle of managing director of Indian Railways? The answer will determine which way the train rolls.
If he decides to be a managing director, he can send out a signal this Thursday by tailoring part of his Budget speech to be that of a company CEO presenting the year’s performance to its shareholders. Prabhu can also revive the stalled project to reform the railways’ accounting system, which will enable that the Indian Railways’ performance is seen in commercial terms.
He needs to set a target for increasing market share in goods movement and identify the target customers for shifting on to rail. For that, an understanding of what the customer considers of value — and creating that value by innovation and investment — is required

Sunday, February 8, 2015

N.O.T.A. - Why Waste a precious vote ?

Dear voters, curb your enthusiasm.
The "none of the above" (NOTA) button that electronic voting machines will have from now on does not give you the 'the right to reject' all candidates.

According to former chief election commissioner S Y Quraishi, the Supreme Court in its order has just given "the right to register a negative opinion."

He said the new provision does not mean that all candidates in a constituency stand rejected or defeated if the number of NOTA votes exceeds the number garnered by the highest vote-getter.

"Even if there are 99 NOTA votes out of a total of 100, and candidate X gets just one vote, X is the winner, having obtained the only valid vote. The rest will be treated as invalid or 'no votes'," Quraishi said in an opinion piece in The Indian Express on Thursday. Quraishi was India's chief election commissioner from June 2010 to July 2012.

He then said that NOTA may not affect election results, the option would "ensure secrecy of the voter wanting to make a choice that amounts to abstention, and also to ensure that nobody casts a bogus vote in his place".

He said the court did not say anything on the right to reject since People's Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL)  which filed the petition demanding NOTA did not ask for the right to reject.

The only use of NOTA, he said citing the order, that it would put "pressure political parties to nominate only good candidates."

On the actual use of NOTA, Quraishi said, was to give privacy to the voter who does not want to vote for any of the candidates in his constituency.
He said when ballot papers were used for voting, voters would put "a blank slip into the ballot box, some would deliberately spoil the ballot by stamping it in more than one place or write sab chor hain (they are all thieves)".

"All these amounted to invalid votes. These were counted but did not have an impact on the result."

But after EVMs came in 1998, that secrecy or the chance to invalid votes was taken away "since the pressing of a button is accompanied by a loud beep, audible in the entire polling booth and even outside. No beep would mean non-voting and everyone would know. This not only violated the voter's secrecy but also made him vulnerable to reprisals."

He said the court order also upheld negative voting.

"A voter may refrain from voting for several reasons, including the reason that he does not consider any of the candidates worthy of his vote. One of the ways of such expression may be to abstain from voting by not turning up at all, which is not an ideal option for a conscientious and responsible citizen. Thus, the only way by which it may be made effectual is by providing a button in the EVMs to express that right. This is the basic requirement if the lasting values in a healthy democracy have to be sustained, which the Election Commission has not only recognised but also asserted."



Sunday, February 1, 2015

MEMORIES OF THE EMERGENCY - L.K Advani

Today, India commands respect in the world, not only because it is perceived as an emerging economic power, but also because from among the developing countries, it is the only one that has been functioning as a vibrant and vigorous democracy.
Within the country, however, many are blissfully unaware that in June 1975 we came very close to a situation when the ruling party wanted to bury multi-party democracy and introduce a single party set up. In my blogs this month, therefore, I have been consciously trying to recall the happenings of the Emergency inflicted on the country on 26th June, 1975.
The country needs to be intensely alive to this phase of independent India’s history. Allowing this phase to be forgotten would be tantamount to doing a grave disservice to Democracy!
As I pointed out last week two events that took place on 12th June, 1975 led to the Emergency. And the Emergency brought to the surface the innate distrust some leaders of the ruling party have always had for democracy. Smt. Gandhi herself once said those days: “The nation is more important than democracy”.
The National Herald, the daily paper in Delhi started by Pandit Nehru, wrote an editorial then praising the one party system in African states like Tanzania as being no less virile than the multi-party system. The paper observed:
“The Westminster model need not be the best model, and some African states have demonstrated how the people’s voice will prevail whatever be the outward structure of democracy. By stressing the need for a strong Centre the PM has pointed out the strength of Indian democracy. A weak Centre threatens the country’s unity, integrity, and very survival of freedom. She has posed the most important question: If the country’s freedom does not survive, how can democracy survive?”
***
Numerous books have been written on the Emergency of 1975. Most of these have been written by Mrs. Gandhi’s critics. These days I am going through an interesting book written by an admirer of hers, Uma Vasudev, a well known journalist who shortly before the imposition of the Emergency had an appreciative book published about her with the title “Indira Gandhi – Revolution in Restraint.”
But the Emergency and all that happened during that period deeply disturbed her.
The upshot was yet another book about the same leader titled “Two faces of Indira Gandhi”.
The book opens with this passage :
“Sitting out in the political cold in the hills of Pachmarhi in June 1976, six hundred miles away from India’s capital, Pandit Dwarka Prasad Mishra, Indira Gandhi’s master tactician and confidant in her battle for intra-party supremacy in 1967-69, related an anecdote to an administrator friend calling on him: “There was a political prisoner I knew in the thirties who was so fond of his pet cat that he was allowed to keep it with him in his cell. One day his nerves cracked and he beat the cat blue. The cat sat cowering in a corner, not knowing where to turn, for the cell door was locked and it was trapped. Each time its one-time protector would come near, it would shrink against the wall and whimper. The jailor heard the cries and came running. As soon as the cell door flew open, the cat, instead of rushing out, leapt at her owner’s throat in such ferocious anger that he nearly died before they could release its grip. The moral of the story is,” said Mishra as his tiny eyes gleamed behind his glasses, “that if you want to hit the enemy, you must leave a way out for him. Otherwise his despair can make him a killer.”
The reference was Maoist but the application was nearer home. It was one year since Indira Gandhi had declared an internal emergency in India on 26 June 1975. The opposition elite was still in jail, including such big names as Jayaprakash Narayan, Morarji Desai, Atal Behari Vajpayee, Raj Narain, L.K. Advani, and Piloo Mody – together with men from her own Congress Party like Chandra Shekhar, Mohan Dharia, Krishan Kant, Ram Dhan, and P.N. Singh. Censorship of the media was still in force. Argument and dissent were mouthed in whispers, while rumour aggravated fear. The politician and the intellectual subsisted in uneasy confrontation, the area of direct knowledge became narrower and narrower, and truth seemed to have more than the seven colours of the rainbow.“
Continuing with this line of analysis, Uma Vasudev writes in the last chapter of her book captioned “Dark Side of the Moon” :
A determined old man walked into Bangalore’s jail one day in June 1976. He wanted to see Lal Krishan Advani, president of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh, who was incarcerated there with a hundred other detenues since the bleak dawn of the emergency. When Advani appeared before him, the man saw a tall, slim, distinguished-looking and fair Sindhi, with very regular features, a moustache, and a quiet manner which gave nothing away.
“Well ?” smiled Advani.
“I’m sixty-five,” the man burst out. “I can’t stand what she’s doing. I’ve done whatever I wanted to. I’ve nothing more to live for. Tell me what to do. I’m prepared to die. I can go and shoot her”.
“No,” said Advani.
But the average worker inside the jails was getting impatient. There was a growing feeling that the leadership within was becoming complacent and that there were no plans towards a new move.
“You seem to think there’s no need to do anything any more,” complained Advani’s companions in prison.
No authoritarian regime had been overthrown by violence, thought Advani. There was no alternative but to wait for the people to rise.
“There was so much anger against Indira Gandhi at the time. Do you think she might possibly have been assassinated then, or if she had managed to scrape back to power later ?” I asked.

“Considering the extent to which she had gone, she might have, perhaps – had this been another country. But not in India. India is too big and it’s not in the temper of the people; otherwise, it would have happened even earlier. Besides, the leadership of the political forces opposed to her is positively opposed to this kind of thing also. They disapprove of these measures. There is too strong a commitment to peace.” Said Advani.
Press censorship during the emergency was extremely strict. Criticism of the Government, the ruling establishment or even of the Emergency was not permitted.
I was therefore surprised to receive in Bangalore jail where I was kept for the greater part of those nineteen months a copy of the QUEST (a quarterly journal from Mumbai dated Nov.-Dec., 1975), which carried an article by Ashis Nandi which in substance said to the rulers that if you persist with your present course of action you would be inviting assassination. The article bore the tell-tale title “Invitation to a Beheading : A psychologist’s guide to assassinations in the third world.
An excerpt from this article read :
“The relationship between an assassin and his victim is deep and enduring. Death only openly and finally brings them together. Of course, there are tyrants who turn virtually everyone in a country into a prospective assassin and leaders who build bastions against their assassination in the minds of men, thereby reducing the circle of prospective assassins to the microscopic group of hired psycho-paths and the mentally ill.
Emperor Nero belonged to the first category and Martin Luther King to the second. There is also the special case of rulers who by the consent of the majority are tyrannical within the country and, to the extent they get the chance, in the world outside. Their pathology leads to collective suicides rather than individual assassinations. Adolf Hitler is the hackneyed but glaring example of the species. But such leaders are hardly typical. There is a much broader range of situations where the ruler is popular and charismatic but propelled by his inner drives, prepares the ground for his assassination. In such cases there is a close fit among the motivational imperatives of such a man, his attempts to remould the polity after his own psychological needs, and the type of invitation he extends to his potential assassins.
The first characteristic of such a ruler is an inability to trust deeply and wholly. Though his flamboyant style may hide it for a long time, he lives in an inner world peopled by untrustworthy men. Even when he trusts some, it is transient. A chain of lieutenants comes in and goes out of his favour in a fashion reminiscent of people getting in and out of a railway compartment.

The ruler suspends this suspiciousness only in the case of his family members, men recruited from outside politics to act as ‘commissars’, and politicians who have no independent bases and are fully dependent on him…”

***
When Uma Vasudev met me after my release and had a long discussion with me about the Emergency happenings, the National Herald’s advocacy of a one party setup like that of Tanzania, (a point that her book referred to above had also mentioned) came up in the discussion. Ms. Vasudev said to me: But is it not true that while this editorial was written on August 11, a fortnight later, on August 25 the same newspaper wrote:
“The PM has made it clear in recent days that there will be no attempt to establish a one party system in this country and that she is not thinking in terms of a constituent assembly or a new Constitution. As far as the party system is concerned, the one party system, however well it might answer needs theoretically, will not be forced; it can come about only in the course of natural evolution, and at present there is no such prospect.”
Uma Vasudev, after citing this statement of the Prime Minister, asked me: “What happened between August 11 and August 25 ?”
My immediate answer was : “Mujib’s assassination on August 15”, I added: “That gave her a shock; and made her realize that the kernel of Democracy must be maintained.”
L.K. Advani
New Delhi
19th June, 2010